Skip to main content

Garden City Watch is an independent civic oversight project. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the City of St. Catharines, the Regional Municipality of Niagara, or any government body.

Garden City WatchPublic record · St. Catharines

Methodology

How the record is kept

The rules are written down so anyone can check our work, and so we can be held to them.

Sourcing

Nothing without a source

  • Every motion, vote, attendance entry and promise change stores a raw reference: the meeting date, the agenda item number and the minutes page or PDF link.
  • The source link is shown on the record itself. If a source cannot be shown, the record is not published.
  • Where data is missing, the page says it is missing. We do not estimate, round up or fill gaps.
  • Attendance counts a member as present when the council minutes list them under Present. A member is counted from their first to their last listed meeting in a term, so someone who joined or left mid-term is not charged with meetings they could not attend.
  • An individual vote is recorded only where the minutes print a recorded vote (Yeas and Nays by name). Votes carried without a recorded vote show who moved the motion but never guess how anyone voted.
  • Map layers and permits come from the City of St. Catharines and Niagara Region open data portals. Transit routes and stops come from the Niagara Region Transit published feed. Fields those sources do not publish are labelled as not published rather than guessed.

Traceability

Who could actually deliver it?

Every promise is classified before it is given a status, so a person is not judged on something outside their power.

Within officeholder's power
The officeholder can deliver the promise on their own authority, for example by directing their own office or by how they vote.
Requires council majority
Delivery depends on a recorded vote of council. One member cannot deliver it alone, so the question is whether they moved it or supported it.
Split with upper tier (Region/Province)
The City shares the decision with Niagara Region or the Province of Ontario, so the City alone cannot fulfil it.
Aspirational / not executable
A goal or value with no executable step that could be checked against a record.

Status

What counts as Delivered, In progress, Pending and Broken

A status only changes when there is cited evidence, and each change is dated in the promise’s evidence trail. The last-verified date is shown on every promise.

Delivered
The promised outcome is documented as complete by a cited source dated on or after the promise.
In progress
A cited action toward the promise has happened (a motion moved, funds committed, work begun) and the promised period has not ended.
Pending
No cited action yet, and the promised period has not ended or no period was stated.
Broken
A cited source shows the promise was voted down, abandoned, reversed, or its stated deadline passed without delivery.

Corrections

Corrections policy

  • If a record is wrong, we correct it and show the correction date on the record.
  • A status is never changed silently. The evidence trail keeps every earlier state.
  • Anyone named in a record may send a source that contradicts it. If the source is primary and verifiable, the record is updated.
  • Garden City Watch is independent and non-partisan. It does not accept payment to add, remove or reword a record.